Chemistry - Atomic Structure Question with Solution | TestHub

ChemistryAtomic StructureGraphs relatedwith radial functionHard2 minQB
ChemistryHardmultiple choice

The same one-electron ion is prepared separately in two pure orbitals P and Q. P has one radial node; Q has none. The electron is less tightly bound in P than in Q. Let be the magnitudes of its orbital angular momentum in the two preparations and let be the magnitude of its intrinsic spin angular momentum, the same in both. A measurement gives

In both preparations the measured spin projection on the laboratory axis is , where . Which statements are correct? Use nonrelativistic one-electron orbital energies, neglect nuclear motion and do not impose optical-transition selection rules between the independently prepared states.

Options:(select one or more)

Answer:
A, C, D
Solution:

An electron has , so its intrinsic magnitude is . The measured projection is and does not replace this magnitude. Thus (a) is true. Using , the measured sum becomes

The nonnegative integer possibilities are . This list is exhaustive: already contributes at least 20, while contributes 0,2,6,12; only and total 12.

The node counts give and . The three assignments are therefore (,), (,) and (,). For the same ion , . Less tightly bound in P means , so (,) is excluded, but the other two assignments both survive. Hence (c) is true, and (d) is true through the pair (,), whose angular-momentum magnitudes both equal .

For the proposed pair (,), , whereas the observed equals . Thus (b) is false. It is exactly the spurious pair obtained by replacing the spin magnitude with its projection magnitude . That error can survive the node-count and binding-order checks, which is why those checks alone cannot validate it. No orbital assignment changes the electron’s intrinsic spin magnitude.

Stream:JEE_ADVSubject:ChemistryTopic:Atomic StructureSubtopic:Graphs relatedwith radial function
⏱ 2mℹ️ Source: QB

Doubts & Discussion

Loading discussions...