Chemistry - Atomic Structure Question with Solution | TestHub
Three separate identical one-electron ions, of unknown positive integer nuclear charge , occupy circular Bohr orbits. Let be each orbit’s circumference and the de Broglie wavelength of its electron. Nuclear motion is neglected. The measured sums are
,
,
where is the stationary-proton hydrogen Bohr radius. Which circumference cannot belong to any of the three ions in any preparation compatible with both observations?
Options:
Answer:
Solution:
Bohr quantization gives , with and . Hence the positive integers satisfy
, and .
The inequality yields , so . Since is a positive integer,.
Order the principal numbers . Then and , so .
For , , : . For , , : . For , , : the roots 2,7 violate . For , , : the roots are not integers (discriminant 28).
Thus the only unordered preparations are and . Their circumference factors in units are respectively and . Factors 25,36,49 are each realized, while 16 never occurs. Although is an allowed isolated hydrogen circumference, it is incompatible with this joint experiment.
