Chemistry - Atomic Structure Question with Solution | TestHub

ChemistryAtomic StructureDe-Broglie Hypothesis, Heisenberg uncertainity principleHard2 minQB
ChemistryHardsingle choice

A nonrelativistic electron enters a one-dimensional electrostatic region at , moving towards increasing with de Broglie wavelength . Its potential energy throughout is , where the real constants are unknown and . Two non-disturbing probes at and report the wavelengths and , but the labels identifying the probes have been lost. It is independently observed that the electron actually reaches in finite time without reversing direction. Treat the trajectory classically and ignore tunnelling.

The greatest de Broglie wavelength attained anywhere during this transit is

Options:

Answer:
B
Solution:

Let and . Energy conservation makes a quadratic with constant term 1. Since , the unlabelled readings imply

Both assignments give positive endpoint kinetic energies, so checking only the probes is insufficient.

If and , the unique interpolating quadratic is

It vanishes at , between the probes, and the slope of is also zero there. Hence both the speed and electrostatic force are zero at that point: it is a classical equilibrium. A smooth conservative trajectory cannot cross this equilibrium with zero speed in finite time. If it were to reach that point at rest, its subsequent classical motion would remain at rest, rather than reaching the second probe. Thus this algebraic assignment cannot describe the observed finite-time transit. The exclusion comes from physical accessibility, not the endpoint energies.

The surviving assignment has and , giving

The minimum is strictly positive and lies inside the region at . Therefore the whole trajectory is accessible and the largest wavelength occurs between the probes, not at the second probe:

Option (a) mistakes the larger probe reading for the global maximum. Option (c) keeps an algebraic assignment that cannot describe the observed transit. Option (d) also neglects the inverse-square relation and the interior extremum.

Stream:JEE_ADVSubject:ChemistryTopic:Atomic StructureSubtopic:De-Broglie Hypothesis, Heisenberg uncertainity principle
⏱ 2mℹ️ Source: QB

Doubts & Discussion

Loading discussions...