Chemistry - Atomic Structure Question with Solution | TestHub
N identical hydrogen-like ions, all in their ground state, absorb N photons of identical energy, exactly one per ion; all ions reach the same bound excited level. Each then makes one complete downward Bohr cascade. A detector records a photon if and only if its energy is at least , where eV. All lower-level transitions are permitted. For which incident photon energies must exactly N photons be recorded in total, irrespective of the cascade routes? Z is an unknown positive integer, and there is no reabsorption.
Options:(select one or more)
Answer:
Solution:
A bound ground-state excitation has with integer n at least 2, so . This small interval identifies the only allowed Z for each option. The four pairs(Z,n) are(2,3),(3,3),(3,4),(4,4), respectively. In(a), the 3-to 2 photon has energy , below the threshold, whereas every final transition to 1 is above threshold. Every cascade therefore yields exactly one detected photon. In(b),3-to 2 has energy , also below threshold, and every final transition to 1 is detected. In(c), the route 4-2-1 yields two detected photons because 4-to 2 has energy ; the direct 4-to 1 route yields only one. In(d),4-to 2 has energy , giving the same counterexample. Thus only(a),(b) give the route-independent guarantee; the total emitted photon count need not equal N.
